Rudlin Consulting Rudlin Consulting
  • About
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Clients
  • Publications
  • Contact us
  • Privacy
  • English
  • About
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Clients
  • Publications
  • Contact us
  • Privacy
  • English
  •  

Tokyo Electron

Home / Posts Tagged "Tokyo Electron"

Tag: Tokyo Electron

Successes and failures of Japanese cross border M&A (Pilkington & Nippon Sheet Glass)

Softbank’s $21bn acquisition of Sprint, the merger of Tokyo Electron and Applied Materials and most recently LIXIL’s 3bn euro acquisition of German bathroom fitting manufacturer Grohe have provoked a two part series in the Nikkei Business magazine on the successes and failures of Japanese cross border M&A, starting with the article of 2nd December, which I read just as I was travelling to Japan to help with a post merger integration project.

Since 2000, domestic M&As have decreased, but cross border M&As have soared for Japanese companies, with a pause after the Lehman Shock in 2009-2011.  Of the 15 M&As noted by the Nikkei from March 2011 to October 2013, 14 were cross border, and the majority were deals of over  $1bn.

The Nikkei comments that although the reason for these acquisitions is clear (the hunt for growth outside the saturated Japanese domestic market), the post merger story has not been that rosy for many of the acquiring companies in the past decade.  The Nikkei focuses on three cases – Nippon Sheet Glass’s acquisition of Pilkington in 2006, Daiichi Sankyo’s acquisition of Ranbaxy in 2008 and Ricoh’s acquisition of US company Ikon Office Solutions in 2008, to see what lessons can be learnt.

Nippon Sheet Glass/Pilkington

NSG were worried that they might be dumped by Toyota, their key customer, if they could not match Toyota’s overseas expansion.  Before the acquisition of Pilkington, 80% of NSG’s sales were in Japan.  Pilkington’s turnover was double that of NSG, so by acquiring it, NSG was finally able to be on equal terms with Asahi (who had previously acquired Saint Gobain).  After the acquisition, the March 2008 results showed that NSG Group sales were 80% overseas, with profits at a record high.  Stuart Chambers and other Pilkington executives took over the key management positions in the group and it seemed as if the company had become global overnight.

However the good times did not last, as the Lehman Shock brought about the world economic crisis, followed by the euro debt crisis, impacting the two main businesses of automotive glass and construction glass.  The NSG management did not take any effective action “and then it hit us” says a Japanese executive at the time “that we knew nothing about Pilkington”.  They thought it would be a growth engine, so did not do anything beyond cut employees and shut down operations.

Too focused on growth and globalization

This is where Japanese M&As often come unstuck says the Nikkei – they are so focused on the growth and globalization, they do not fully develop strategies and pathways for ensuring the M&A actually bears fruit.  “We had to focus on the immediate crisis, rather than the growth of the new company” says Kazumitsu Fujii, an executive officer.

NSG did know Pilkington quite well – having held equity in the company since 2000, and collaborated on various projects together.  Howerver they had not undertaken any simulation of the financial impacts of any worsening market conditions post merger.  As one executive at the time says “we did not even have any thought that the economic situation would get so bad so quickly”.

Stuart Chambers resigned in September 2009, citing family pressures from being in Japan all the time – and it was felt that his heart was not really in the job.

NSG had a 4-3-3 10 year vision.  The first four years were to be about integrating the two companies’ systems and cutting down the debts.  The next three years were to expand sales in automotive and construction glass and the second 3 years were to be about investing in new businesses.

However the company has not managed to move on from the first phase yet.  It seems that the lack of understanding and knowledge between the two companies has meant that the negative financial situation has dragged on.  “We thought that once we had made the leap into being a global company, all kinds of paths would open up to us, but it was not the case” says a former employee.

The new President, Keiji Yoshikawa says “we are having to fix areas we did not see at the time of the acquisition”.  Pilkington had centralised, standardized global HR management and sales systems which looked efficient at first glance, but meant that there were regional differences which were ignored.

For example, construction glass has to take account of the different climates and lifestyles, but apparently such products were not given much priority.  So NSG have started to allocate budgets to projects such as fire resistant glass in Germany.

After 7 years, NSG have finally started to understand Pilkington, concludes Nikkei Business.

Standardization and taking the initiative

My personal thoughts on this, having conducted various cross cultural communications seminars for Pilkington and Nippon Sheet Glass at the time, was that the two companies knew each other pretty well.  The gap was more to do with differing views and levels of experience in managing globally.

Pilkington, like many Anglo Saxon multinationals, would indeed emphasise a standard unified approach to management and product development around the world, in order to ensure maximum profitability.  The Japanese view that products should be customised to suit different markets is not cost effective, in this world view.

The other issue, as is so often the case when Japanese companies acquire Western ones, is that both parties sit back and wait for the other to take the initiative – and this was amplified by the Lehman Shock – where quick and decisive action was needed.  Pilkington may well have expected NSG to take the lead, whereas NSG was expecting Pilkington to have the global experience to provide the guidance for what to do in such extreme circumstances.

For more content like this, subscribe to the free Rudlin Consulting Newsletter. 最新の在欧日系企業の状況については無料の月刊Rudlin Consulting ニューズレターにご登録ください。

Share Button
Read More

Last updated by Pernille Rudlin at 2021-10-20.

Search

Recent Posts

  • Clear trends from less data on Japanese companies in Europe
  • Toshiba launches quantum technology hub in Cambridge, UK
  • Japan’s M3 acquires British medical staffing company Messly
  • Japan owned British crypto currency firm B2C2 acquires France based Woorton
  • Dentsu acquires Germany’s RCKT

Categories

  • Africa
  • Brexit
  • China and Japan
  • Corporate brands, values and mission
  • Corporate culture
  • Corporate Governance
  • cross cultural awareness
  • CSR
  • customer service
  • Digital Transformation
  • Diversity & Inclusion
  • European companies in Japan
  • European identity
  • Foreign Direct Investment
  • Globalization
  • History of Japanese companies in UK
  • Human resources
  • Innovation
  • Internal communications
  • Japanese business etiquette
  • Japanese business in Europe
  • Japanese customers
  • M&A
  • Management and Leadership
  • Marketing
  • Middle East
  • negotiation
  • Presentation skills
  • Reputation
  • Seminars
  • speaker events
  • Trade
  • Uncategorized
  • Virtual communication
  • webinars
  • Women in Japanese companies
  • Working for a Japanese company
  • Zero carbon

RSS Rudlin Consulting

  • Clear trends from less data on Japanese companies in Europe
  • Toshiba launches quantum technology hub in Cambridge, UK
  • Japan’s M3 acquires British medical staffing company Messly
  • Japan owned British crypto currency firm B2C2 acquires France based Woorton
  • Dentsu acquires Germany’s RCKT
  • Nippon Express acquires Switzerland based Tramo Group
  • Hitachi divests UK’s Temple Lifts
  • GMO Internet to close GMO-Z.COM London forex brokerage
  • SMFG continues its restructuring in EMEA
  • Japanese financial services companies in the UK

Search

Affiliates

Japan Intercultural Consulting

Cross cultural awareness training, coaching and consulting. 異文化研修、エグゼクティブ・コーチング と人事コンサルティング。

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Email Format

To receive the newsletter, please tick "Email" below. Rudlin Consulting Ltd will also use the information you provide on this form to be in touch with you and to provide updates and marketing by email.

You can change your mind at any time by clicking the unsubscribe link in the footer of any email you receive from us, or by contacting us at pernille.at.rudlinconsulting.dot.com. We will treat your information with respect. For more information about our privacy practices please visit our website. By clicking below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.

We use MailChimp as our marketing platform. By clicking below to subscribe, you acknowledge that your information will be transferred to MailChimp for processing. Learn more about MailChimp's privacy practices here.

Recent Blogposts

  • Clear trends from less data on Japanese companies in Europe
  • Toshiba launches quantum technology hub in Cambridge, UK
  • Japan’s M3 acquires British medical staffing company Messly
  • Japan owned British crypto currency firm B2C2 acquires France based Woorton
  • Dentsu acquires Germany’s RCKT

Rudlin Consulting on Twitter

  • RT @Ravilious1942: Road by an Airfield, Eric Ravilious, c.1942. The original artwork was sold at @ChristiesInc in 2008 and is now believed… 09:11:29 PM May 22, 2023 from Twitter Web App ReplyRetweetFavorite
  • RT @EmilieCope91: Calling female colleagues Karens is a new and exciting way for men to be sexist at work. 09:31:03 PM May 20, 2023 from Twitter for Android ReplyRetweetFavorite
  • RT @Ravilious1942: The Causeway, Wiltshire Downs, Eric Ravilious, 1937. The original artwork is in the collection of @V_and_A. #Wiltshire… 06:20:26 PM May 20, 2023 from Twitter for Android ReplyRetweetFavorite
  • @katebevan Eww. Wish I hadn't asked now. Can't unread. 12:27:37 PM May 20, 2023 from Twitter for Android in reply to katebevan ReplyRetweetFavorite
@pernilleru

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
Privacy Policy

Privacy Policy

Web Development: counsell.com